Caraway 2-Piece Nonstick Baking Sheet Set & Reviews

Color/Finish:

Gray

Features

Product Type

Baking Sheet

Material

Aluminized Steel

Product Care

Hand wash recommended, Clean with cloth, mild soap, and warm water

Total Number of Pieces Included

PTFE / PFOA Free

PFOA Free, PTFE Free

General Features

Non-Stick

Set / Single

Set

Customer Reviews

Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars.

1,762 Reviews

What Everyone's Saying

Customers praise the product for its exceptional ease of cleaning and high-quality construction. The attractive appearance and reliable performance, including even baking and non-stick properties, are frequently highlighted. While durability is generally viewed positively, with some noting they look new after extended use, one review mentioned warping at high temperatures.

AI-generated from customer reviews

Showing 1-5 of 1,762 reviews

Filter by keyword

Most relevant

Sort By

Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

LilaBoston

Color/Finish:Cream

10/30/2026

Rated 3 out of 5 stars.

DeniseNew Jersey

Color/Finish:Cream

I have Caraway cookware that I love but the baking sheet not so much. They are nonstick and pretty but not great for baking. Cookies cook unevenly and too dark on bottom.

08/21/2026

Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

JillUS

Color/Finish:Cream

I absolutely love my Caraway pans. They heat evenly, look beautiful on my stovetop, and clean up so easily. I appreciate the non-toxic coating and how effortlessly food releases without needing much oil. They’ve quickly become my go-to for everyday cooking and still look brand new. Stylish, functional, and totally worth it.

12/29/2025

Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

ClaudiaUS

Color/Finish:Navy

Caraway is always a guarantee, we loved the trays, we ordered them in blue. We switch to organic and healthy products and with Caraway you get a great product for your cooking. The handles in the big one are very handy!

12/06/2025

Rated 5 out of 5 stars.

DianaCollege Station, TX

Color/Finish:Gray

Beautiful! Love my new baking sheets!

09/16/2025

Compare Similar Items

Caraway Nonstick Baking Sheet

$65

Caraway's 18" x 13" Large Baking Sheet is the easy-to-handle answer for big batches of everything. Use for baking, roasting, and more. Featuring a non-toxic, naturally slick ceramic coating, healthy baking has never been easier.

Great product....... Caraway is a top notch company. Ronnie. Indianapolis, IN. Mon Apr 13 2026

Caraway Nonstick Baking Sheet

$55

Caraway's 15" x 10" Medium Baking Sheet is all you'll need for no-fuss baking: use for half a dozen cookies, sweet potato fries, and more. Featuring a naturally slick, non-toxic ceramic-coated interior, this sheet makes healthy baking (and clean up) easier than ever.

Love caraway don’t need any sprays and everything slides right off, feel confident cooking for my kids on these pans. Emerald. Boston, MA. Tue Nov 04 2025